High Yield Vs. DGI Vs. Index Funds: What Actually Works Best For Retirement Income?

Last summer I wrote an article about a study I performed to see how high yield investments would have fared compared to dividend growth investments and index funds since 2010. High yield investments which pay out over 10% had been touted as being a solution for retirees (and near-retirees) who had not saved enough to generate their desired level of income from the dividends paid by traditional DGI investments or index funds. The theory expressed by the proponents of high yield was that even if there's little or no growth in the value of the individual securities in the portfolio the income thrown off by the higher dividends was enough to pay the retiree a substantial income and also generate an excess that could be plowed back into the portfolio, growing its value through reinvestment. I wanted to perform a five-year back check to see if it worked.
The study was simple: I found two ten-stock model portfolios suggested by proponents of high yield investment strategies ("50-50" and "MRHY"), another ten-stock model portfolio suggested by a proponent of dividend growth investing -- DGI -- and selected two index funds. I did not choose any of the model portfolios myself, but relied on the suggested investments advanced by proponents of each philosophy in 2014 and 2015.
I checked the price each security was trading at on July 1, 2010 (or the earliest available date thereafter) and "bought" $50,000 worth of each of the individual securities in the... Read more